Alimentation Couche-Tard Inc.’s decision to walk away in frustration from an attempted acquisition of Seven & i Holdings Co. set off a debate in Tokyo as to what lessons foreign companies with ambitions for M&A should draw.

Couche-Tard, the operator of Circle K stores, after it said the 7-Eleven owner, Seven & i Holdings, refused to engage constructively on the deal.

Shares in Couche-Tard jumped 8 per cent higher Thursday after the company announced it was dropping its quest to acquire the Japanese company